Confucius paid great attention to courtesy, and in his eyes, public etiquette was great than personal affection. He believed that it was the existence of public etiwuette that could maintain the order of the dynasty. And Yan Hui was his best disciple, so Confucius knew that Yan Hui would understand and respect his etiquette, and would not feel that he was ruthless.
教学团队
课程特色
视频(28)
考试(25)
文档(3)
讨论(3)
最新学员
Sharing your ideas of Confucius's choice on Yan Yuan's funeral.
Question: How do you comment on Confucius’s refusal to pay for buying a shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin? Does it show Confucius's lack of sincerity in his "love" toward his so-called "favorite" student?
345 回复
-
-
-
-
-
After the unfortunate death of Yan yuan, Confucius did not follow the trend in the face of his disciples and Yan's father's request for a generous burial, but stuck to the Confucian etiquette, believing that funerals should be based on sincerity and should not pursue material luxury. His refusal to sell cars and make coffers was not only a consideration of Yan Hui's family's economic situation, but also a adherence to the Confucian principles of frugality and respect for etiquette, rather than a lack of sincerity in his love for him
-
Confucius’ refusal to pay for an expensive shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin does not necessarily indicate a lack of sincerity in his love for Yan Yuan. Instead, it reflects his deep commitment to the principles of propriety, frugality, moral integrity, and respect for tradition. His decision was guided by a broader ethical framework that prioritized the values he taught over personal sentiment. This demonstrates that Confucius’ love for Yan Yuan was genuine but expressed through adherence to these higher principles.
-
I deeply respect and admire Confucius' choice at the funeral of Yan Yuan, which fully showcases his wisdom and benevolence. Firstly, as a great thinker and educator, Confucius knew the importance of rituals in maintaining social order and promoting peace of mind. At the funeral of his beloved disciple Yan Yuan, Confucius insisted on following the ritual norms of the time, which was a show of respect for Yan Yuan and an upholding of the ritual system. His choice undoubtedly demonstrated the solemnity and holiness of rituals and emphasized the indispensability of rituals in people's lives. Secondly, Confucius' choice at Yan Yuan's funeral also showed his deep affection for Yan Yuan. Yan Yuan was Confucius' favorite disciple, and they had a close relationship. Confucius had high expectations for Yan Yuan. Yan Yuan's death was a huge blow to Confucius, but he did not lose his mind, choosing to express his grief through rituals. This way of expressing emotions through rituals not only demonstrated Confucius' depth and restraint, but also showed his boundless yearning and reverence for Yan Yuan.
In summary, Confucius' choice at Yan Yuan's funeral was wise and benevolent. He not only upheld the dignity and holiness of rituals, but also expressed his deep affection for Yan Yuan through rituals. This choice not only conformed to the social norms of the time, but also gained widespread recognition and acclaim in terms of morality and emotions.
-
Confucius’s refusal to sell his carriage to buy a shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin does not necessarily indicate a lack of sincerity in his love for his student. Instead, it reflects Confucius’s adherence to the principles of propriety (Li) and his understanding of the appropriate social conduct expected of him as a person of his status. According to the Analects of Confucius, when Yan Yuan died, Yan Yuan’s father, Yan Lu, asked Confucius to sell his carriage to buy an outer coffin for Yan Yuan. Confucius responded by saying that when his own sondied, he had a coffin but not an outer shell, and he did not sell his carriage to buy one because it was not proper for him, as someone who had followed in the rear of the great officers, to walk on foot.
-
1. Adherence to Ritual (Li): Confucius was a staunch believer in the importance of ritual and propriety. The decision not to purchase a shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin could be seen as an adherence to the established rituals of the time. In ancient China, there were strict social hierarchies and rituals that dictated how funerals should be conducted, including the type of coffin and burial practices. Confucius may have been following these customs to maintain social order and respect for tradition.
2. Financial Prudence: Confucius was also known for his practicality and financial prudence. As a teacher, he may have been aware of the financial strain that a lavish funeral could place on Yan Yuan’s family. By not purchasing an expensive shell, Confucius could have been showing consideration for the family’s financial well-being, which is also a form of care and respect.
3. Expression of Grief: The refusal to buy a shell does not necessarily indicate a lack of sincerity or love for Yan Yuan. In Confucian thought, actions are often more important than material expressions. Confucius’s grief and respect for Yan Yuan could have been expressed in other ways, such as through the depth of his teachings, the influence he had on Yan Yuan’s life, and the legacy he left behind.
4. Teaching Moment: Confucius often used life’s events as teaching moments. His actions regarding Yan Yuan’s funeral could have been a lesson for his other students about the importance of following rituals, managing finances wisely, and understanding that true respect and love are not solely measured by material offerings.
5. Cultural Context: It’s important to consider the cultural context of the time. In ancient China, the concept of “face” and social standing were crucial. Confucius’s actions could have been a way to maintain the dignity and social standing of Yan Yuan’s family by ensuring that the funeral was conducted in a manner befitting their status.
In conclusion, Confucius’s refusal to buy a shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin does not necessarily reflect a lack of sincerity or love. Instead, it can be seen as a complex decision influenced by his adherence to ritual, financial prudence, the expression of grief in a manner consistent with his teachings, and the cultural norms of the time. Confucius’s actions should be understood within the broader context of his philosophy and the society in which he lived. -
Confucius had deep affection and respect for his students. In that era, there were specific cultural and ritual norms. His actions might be due to various considerations within the framework of those norms and not an indication of lack of sincerity. Confucius dedicated his life to teaching and guiding his students, imparting moral and intellectual knowledge. We should view historical events and figures in the context of their times rather than making unfounded speculations and misjudgments. His relationship with his students was complex and based on the pursuit of virtue and wisdom, not to be simply questioned in such a one-sided way.
-
Because Confucius insisted on burying his beloved students according to "ritual" and firmly opposed excessive burial beyond the scope of "ritual", even though Yan Yuan's father requested that his teacher Confucius sell his special car to buy an outer coffin for Yan Yuan, Confucius firmly disagreed. This is not a sign that he doesn't love his students.
-
Confucius's refusal to pay for buying a shell for Yan Yuan's coffin can be seen as a manifestation of his deep love and respect for his disciple. Confucius's actions reflect his belief that the value of a person's life cannot be measured by material possessions or wealth. Instead, it is the inner qualities and virtues that truly matter. By refusing to pay for the shell, Confucius demonstrated his commitment to upholding these values and his deep love and respect for Yan Yuan. Therefore, it does not show a lack of sincerity in his "love" toward his so-called "favorite" student, but rather a profound expression of his love and respect for him.
-
Confucius's refusal to pay for a shell to be used as a coffin for his favorite student, Yan Yuan, can be interpreted in various ways, reflecting the complexities of Confucian thought and the values that Confucius espoused.
▎Context of the Incident
In the context of the story, Yan Yuan was one of Confucius's most esteemed disciples, known for his dedication and moral integrity. When he passed away, the need for a proper burial was significant, as Confucian values place great importance on filial piety and respect for the dead. The shell in question was likely a costly item, and Confucius's refusal to pay for it raises questions about his attitude toward material wealth and his understanding of love and duty.
▎Possible Interpretations
1. Principle Over Materialism: Confucius often emphasized the importance of moral values over material possessions. His refusal to spend money on the shell might reflect a belief that true respect for Yan Yuan transcends material offerings. In this view, Confucius's actions could be seen as a commitment to the principles of simplicity and moderation rather than an indication of insincerity in his feelings for Yan Yuan.
2. Teaching Moment: Confucius may have intended to use this situation as a teaching moment, illustrating to his other disciples the importance of prioritizing moral values over extravagant displays of grief or respect. By refusing to indulge in what he may have viewed as unnecessary expenditure, he could be reinforcing the idea that true love and respect are shown through virtuous actions rather than material gifts.
3. Personal Integrity: Confucius's actions might also reflect his personal integrity and adherence to his own teachings. He often advocated for self-discipline and restraint, and by refusing to spend money he may not have had or wished to part with, he could be embodying the very virtues he taught.
4. Emotional Complexity: It is also possible to argue that this incident highlights the complexity of human emotions and relationships. While Confucius may have genuinely cared for Yan Yuan, his refusal could suggest a struggle between emotional attachment and philosophical principles. This complexity does not necessarily indicate a lack of sincerity but rather illustrates the challenges inherent in balancing personal feelings with ethical considerations.
▎Conclusion
In conclusion, Confucius's refusal to pay for the shell for Yan Yuan's coffin can be interpreted in multiple ways. It does not straightforwardly indicate a lack of sincerity in his affection for Yan Yuan; rather, it reflects Confucian values regarding materialism, moral integrity, and the nature of love. The incident invites deeper reflection on how love can manifest in ways that prioritize moral principles over material expressions, ultimately reinforcing the idea that true respect and affection are rooted in virtue rather than mere financial expenditure.
-
Confucius's refusal to pay for buying a shell for Yan Yuan's coffin has been interpreted in various ways, but it does not necessarily reflect a lack of sincerity in his love for his favorite student. In Confucian ethics, there is a strong emphasis on propriety and ritual, which often dictates specific actions and behaviors in different situations. It is possible that Confucius, as a strict adherent to these principles, believed that paying for the shell would violate certain rites or customs related to mourning and burial practices.
Moreover, Confucius's love for Yan Yuan was profound and manifested in many ways throughout their relationship. His teaching, guidance, and support for Yan Yuan were testament to his deep affection and commitment to his student's growth and development. Therefore, it is unfair to judge Confucius's sincerity based solely on this one incident, which should be understood in the context of the broader Confucian ethical framework.
-
Under the etiquette of the time, Confucius, as a nobleman, could not travel without a vehicle, which was a compliance with etiquette; moreover, Confucius treated his students equally, and did not use a coffin for his own son when he passed away, treating Yan Yuan the same; at the same time, Confucius was well aware of Yan Yuan‘s virtue of being content with poverty and pursuing virtues, from this perspective, Yan Yuan himself may not have wanted to violate the principle of frugality, so it cannot be concluded that Confucius's love for Yan Yuan was not sincere.
-
Confucius' refusal to sell his own car to purchase an outer coffin for Yan Yuan was based on respect for propriety and his own status. His own son Carp died with only an inner coffin but not an outer coffin, and he did not walk to buy an outer coffin for his son because as an official, it would be unseemly for him to walk. This shows that Confucius' behavior was based on his adherence to the social etiquette of the time rather than a lack of love for Yan Yuan.
添加回复
您确定给 “0” 位老师发送协议吗？
UMOOCS用户服务协议
问题分类：
--
